How to respond to online patient reviews under HIPAA
A working handbook for practice groups. It explains the rule, the risks and the replies, and ends with a policy your staff can follow. It is general information, not legal advice.
1. Why free speech does not cover a HIPAA disclosure
A patient can say anything about their own care in a public review. A practice cannot answer with details of that care. The HIPAA Privacy Rule limits what a covered entity discloses, and a public reply is a disclosure. The reviewer going first does not give the practice permission to confirm or add to what they said.
Practices have argued that they were only correcting the record. HHS OCR has not accepted that as a reason to disclose protected health information, and it has settled cases with practices over review replies.
2. Four questions OCR asks about a review reply
Reading the published resolutions, the same questions come up. This is our reading, not an official checklist.
- Did the reply disclose PHI? Confirming someone is a patient, naming a service, a date, a condition or a bill.
- Was there an authorization? A signed authorization that covers the disclosure. A review is not one.
- Was there a policy? A written policy on social media and review replies.
- Were staff trained and was risk assessed? Training records and a risk analysis that covers online replies.
3. Reviews from people you cannot find in your records
It is tempting to reply that the person was never a patient. That is still a statement about patient status. Reply as you would to any review: thanks, your standards and a private route. If the review breaks the platform's rules, report it through the platform.
4. Scripts for billing, outcomes and staff complaints
Each script below leaves out everything that identifies a person. The full set of twenty is in the reply template library.
Billing complaint
Thank you for taking the time to write. Clear billing matters to us, and we want every bill to make sense. Privacy law keeps us from discussing any individual's account in public, so please contact our practice manager at the number or email on our profile. They can review the details with you directly.
Unhappy clinical outcome
Thank you for sharing your concerns. We take every concern about care seriously and want to understand what happened. Federal privacy rules keep us from discussing anyone's care in a public forum, so please contact our practice manager at the number or email on our profile. A member of our leadership team will follow up with you directly.
Rude front desk staff
Thank you for telling us. Everyone who contacts our office should be treated with courtesy, and we are sharing this feedback with our team leads. Please contact our practice manager directly if you would like to talk about it further.
5. A review reply policy for clinic staff
Adapt this text with your privacy officer and counsel before you adopt it.
Purpose. To protect patient privacy when the practice replies to online reviews.
Who may reply. Only staff named by the privacy officer, after approval in the review tool.
What a reply may contain. Thanks for the feedback, a general statement of the practice's standards, and a role and channel for a private conversation.
What a reply must never contain. Confirmation that the reviewer is or was a patient; any service, condition, date, provider in a clinical context, bill, balance or insurance detail; any argument about the facts.
Escalation. Reviews that mention injury, infection, medication, a lawyer, a lawsuit or a licensing board go to the clinical director and the privacy officer before any reply.
Training. Staff who reply complete training on this policy when they start and every year.